Compassion for Animals
نویسنده
چکیده
actions.2 Both models maintain that compassion is made possible by the ability of the one who feels compassion (source) to identify with the plight of the individual for whom compassion is felt (target).3 They diverge in their analyses ofhow identification is achieved. One account, advanced separately by Lawrence A. Blum and Adrian M. S. Piper, contends that imaginative reconstruction of the other's subjective experiences is necessary for identification.4 The alternative, which I develop, denies that imagination is required for identification, but admits that it can playa facilitating role. That the source has a particular set of beliefs, including beliefs about the I target's vulnerability and its role in occasioning the target's plight, as well as beliefs about the source's My thesis is that it can be, and frequently is, rational similar vulnerability and consequent liability to for humans to feel compassion for nonhuman animals. misfortune, can suffice for identification.5 Compassion for animals can be explained by examining Examining compassion for nonhuman animals not several modes of connection between humans and other only reveals the limitations of the imagination-based animals. The connections encompass modes of account; it also underscores some advantages of the identification between humans and other animals, for belief-based model. The weaknesses of the BlumJPiper example: imaginative reconstructions of their subjective view are discussed in part II. The contention ofpart III is experiences, beliefs about humans and other animals, that the original version of the belief-based model can including beliefs about similarities between species, be amended to explain how human compassion for other other emotions toward animals, such as kinship feelings, animals is possible, appropriate, and rational. Part IV and outlooks or ways of life that reflect value judgments concludes by briefly sketching conditions under which about and attitudes toward nonhuman animals. To feel compassion is misnamed, misplaced, or irrational. compassion for animals is to be connected with them A preliminary comment. Both accounts presuppose in an especially complex way. The challenge of this a cognitively complex conception ofemotion, according essay is to comprehend this connection. Two competing accounts of compassion have emerged in recent philosophical literature. l Both rely on a core definition of compassion as an intense emotional response to the misfortune of another, which includes suffering with the other, and concern for the other's good. This concern is frequently expressed in benevolent other-regarding thoughts, desires, and
منابع مشابه
Commentary: How Can We Have Compassion Towards Animals?
Professor Snow has offered an original and illuminating analysis of compassion which, among its other virtues, provides a plausible account of why we feel compassion for animals and why it is rational to do so. I fully endorse her general approach, so my comments will not be in any wayan attempt to undermine or refute her analysis; instead, I wish to raise some questions that follow on the heel...
متن کاملCompassion for animals in the laboratory: impairment or refinement of research methodology?
There are now signs in the United States as well as in Europe that the importance of a positive human-nonhuman animal relationship in research laboratories is appreciated more seriously. In addition to knowledge and skills, primary attributes of animal research personnel must be feelings of compassion and sensitivity toward animals to safeguard the reliability of scientific research data.
متن کاملChildhood Attachment to Pets: Associations between Pet Attachment, Attitudes to Animals, Compassion, and Humane Behaviour
Attachment to pets has an important role in children's social, emotional, and cognitive development, mental health, well-being, and quality of life. This study examined associations between childhood attachment to pets and caring and friendship behaviour, compassion, and attitudes towards animals. This study also examined socio-demographic differences, particularly pet ownership and pet type. A...
متن کاملA Brief Outline of the Evolutionary Approach for Compassion Focused Therapy
Humans are evolved animals set up to pursue various life tasks. This gives rise to different phenotypes some of which are conducive to well-being, while others are not. Compassion focused therapy seeks to harness the evolved importance of affiliative and caring motivational processing to help alleviate individuals who are caught in high levels of shame and self-criticism and consequent depressi...
متن کاملHow Japanese companion dog and cat owners’ degree of attachment relates to the attribution of emotions to their animals
Recently, studies in the United States and European countries have shown that the degree of attachment is associated with the attribution of emotions to companion animals. These studies imply that investigating the degree of attachment to companion animals is a good way for researchers to explore animal emotions and then improve animal welfare. Although a promising area of study, in Japan, no e...
متن کامل